Welcome to www.newsmedianews.com - the connected place

MP3 MUSIC

True ghost story

Poetry

Search Site

within using

OLD & NEW

Oldest intelligent homo sapien remains found in Ireland
Kerry farmer apologises for horrific â€˜mix-upâ€™
Elmo Maheeny has been replaced by Rumpold Slitskin
What a Load of Trashâ€”self-generating trash research report
Our world today
Of Cannabis Freedom and Dictators
BÃ¶rhd Hooligan goes ballistic
Reporters Without Borders - Freedom of Information
Crippling the Killing Machine â€”Hermit Empeysex on war
Contribute news direct to this website
Poll results say 'No-DSS' advertising 'unlawful and discriminatory'
Newsmedianews features index
The basement Years mp3 collection
A Question of Education? Perhapsâ€”but whose? - Hermit Empeysex reports
An examination of Britain's ''improved' state welfare system
Lord Knoxborough still missing
Vote on a range of current and other issues
An encounter with the UK D-Notice-archived yarn
News from the European Union
Newsmedianews forum
Editorial
Our Muppet Democracies - Hermit Empeysex
Exclusive - the Toise Collection

Selected direct news input items

Dutch court ruling undermines net neutrality printable version

14 Feb 2019: posted by the editor - Internet news, European Union, Holland

By David Korteweg, EDRi member Bits of Freedom, the Netherlands
According to the court, the mobile operator T-Mobile may continue to provide certain music services with preferential treatment to its customers in the Netherlands − a disappointing judgment showing the need for better rules.

T-Mobile has thrown the principle of net neutrality overboard with their “Data-Free Music” service. This service provides certain music streaming services with preferential treatment over other services, as long as they fulfil the conditions set by T-Mobile. This practice is called “zero rating”. To get preferential treatment, the provider of the service must not only fit within the mold of a “music streaming service” as defined by T-Mobile, it must also meet the legal and technical requirements, again set by T-Mobile. This means that music streaming services that do not make it to this list are in a disadvantageous position compared to its listed competitors.

In 2018, Dutch EDRi member Bits of Freedom appealed the decision of the national regulatory authority (ACM) not to act against T-Mobile's “Data-free Music” service. The administrative court of first instance ruled in favour of T-Mobile: the service does not violate the net neutrality rules and the ACM does not have to act.

Unfortunately, due to procedural reasons, the court does not get to a substantive judgment on the first part of the appeal. Bits of Freedom argued that the European net neutrality rules prohibit the preferential treatment of traffic from certain services by not charging this traffic to users. The court defers to its previous judgment about this service in a case between T-Mobile and the ACM. In that judgment, it ruled that the prohibition on unequal treatment of traffic is limited to the technical treatment of traffic. The economic treatment of traffic is not covered, according to the court. The court considers this ruling to also bind the court in the case Bits of Freedom appealed.

The non-discrimination principle contained in the European net neutrality guidelines should apply to the treatment of traffic, regardless of whether that treatment involves delaying or blocking traffic or applying a different price for traffic. It is true that certain forms of differential technical treatment of traffic (so called “traffic management”) are admissible under the net neutrality rules, but this does not automatically mean that the general standard to treat traffic equally is limited only to the technical treatment of traffic.

In the second part of the appeal, Bits of Freedom explains why the zero rating service “Data-Free Music” limits the rights of end users and is therefore in violation of the net neutrality rules. An essential part of net neutrality is that an internet user is free to determine which information, services or applications they use, without interference by an internet access provider. T-Mobile is doing exactly that: it influences how certain services are treated for economic reasons. The ACM did not agree on this argument, and the court of first instance upheld ACM's decision, unfortunately.

This judgment makes it clear that the current interpretation of the European net neutrality rules by ACM and the Dutch court is a deterioration compared to the previous net neutrality rules in the Netherlands since 2012 and before the European law came into effect.

Under those rules internet access providers could not treat services unequally by charging different prices for data traffic. Dutch internet users are therefore currently less protected against practices that undermine the open and innovative nature of the internet.

In 2019, the Body of European Regulators (BEREC) will review the guidelines that protect net neutrality. The current judgment shows that it is essential that the application of the rules about zero-rating, and ultimately the rules themselves, will be improved. Only this will ensure strong net neutrality in Europe.

Bits of Freedom https://www.bitsoffreedom.nl/

Time for better net neutrality rules (06.02.2019) https://www.bitsoffreedom.nl/2019/02/06/time-for-better-net-neutrality-rules/

Bits of Freedom’s court case about zero rating (06.08.2018) https://www.bitsoffreedom.nl/2018/08/06/bits-of-freedoms-court-case-about-zero-rating/

Judgment of the administrative court of first instance (only in Dutch, 24.01.2019) https://www.bitsoffreedom.nl/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/rb-rotterdam-24-01-2019-netneutraliteit-bits-of-freedom-ecli-nl-rbot-2019-414.pdf

T-Mobile treats everyone equally unequally (21.02.2018) https://edri.org/t-mobile-treats-everyone-equally-unequally/

Tags: net neutrality european union

Back to headlines
comments (0)
recommend

>Local comment

Name: Remember me

E-mail: (optional)

Captcha

NEWS + LINKS + NEWS + LINKS + NEWS

Direct news input publishing
Into the 21s Century
Are we sliding headlong down an accelerating curve of social
madness and state sanctioned discrimination and prejudice?
Borhd Hooligan writes
The Weary Web Traveller
Hypocrisy, Hatred and the war on Terror
An encounter with the UK government's D-Notice
Headlines from Ireland

Other News
Downing Street news
While House news
from the Middle-East
from Limerick, Ireland
Ireland and Europe
Report from Afghanistan
An Asian Encounter
News From America
News from Ireland
The war against SPAM
f Borhd Hooligan's column
Ending the spread of violence
Giant tsunami poised to strike US east coast – science article

_____________________________
stored items
f When Flesh & Blood are forgotten by Ramadan Akin
f The world at war
f War by Television — a backward view?- by Noel Yotslot
f Terrorism– is there any answer?
money laundering scams - confirm details here

f Religion – are you into it ?
f What price the truth? by Keith Harris
f Sex, love & rock'n'roll with Arnold Layne & Knickers McFee
f The Professional Bums
f Making the world a better place, but for who?
f Climate change – too little too late?
f Friends & Educating Rita
Christmas in Bosnia

SPECIAL REPORTS
Arnold Schwarzenegger denies beach bully rumour
* EXCLUSIVE—IRELAND RE-REINTRODUCES RAT TAX *
Ireland perfects brutunschweier clogomitis antidote
Limerick man first reported victim of brutunschweier clogomitis beetle
crop circles - the secret revealed
Ireland’s grollybelium tank uncovered
The Clonakilty cloning farm
Ranns invasion - latest details
Rare Tasmanian flea reported in Ireland
Knoxborough Hall — police stiill no closer to locating stolen stately home
Gorilla terrifies Limerick security guard
SWAPPA takes to the skies Hailed as Irish blueprint for future aircraft
Evidence emerges from the ice on human evolution exclusive
300 million year old Yeti unearthed in Ireland
Maggot colony disrupts airport flight schedule
News – is it worth it? – special report

Ñ general item f feature

Article of the Day

This day in history

Today's birthday

World Headlines

Some day you'll find everything you're looking for
a funny thing happened to me on the way to ...
reader opinion page
Click to check your browser compatibility and integrity
latest Internet security alerts
Traffic details for this site
Make Newsmedianews.your home page

Europe | Other Irish Snips | Business News |Voices of America

Submit Your Site
<List your site at Newsmedianews> | <What's New?> | <Try the Boring competition>
Click to check your browser compatibility with this site

GOT NEWS ?

Founder member of ISCOM
HARRIS-KHIOS Inc.1391
Member of International Guild of Editors

Web site hosted by www.letshost.ie
Constructed using Macromedia software
Supported by all Good Folk everywhere

&
all major credit cards accepted