PALESTINE NEWS

 


main headlines                      News links from Palestine

GAZA STRIP MESSAGE BOARD
News sources from Palestine
American Task Force/Mid East news round-up
Newsmedianews ads
Great Deals on Books, Music & Movies at Alibris!
Software store
    + Larger Font | - Smaller Font
    View all direct news items          Search Direct Input items

 

 

Direct news input story index

No current entries to show                                   What’s this?

More from Ireland at www.thetruth.ie

Direct news input items


COVID-Tech: the sinister consequences of immunity passports       printable version
10 Jun 2020: posted by the editor - Features, Health, Human Rights, Technology, International

By EDRi.org
In EDRi’s series on COVID-19, COVIDTech, we explore the critical principles for protecting fundamental rights while curtailing the spread of the virus, as outlined in the EDRi network’s statement on the pandemic. Each post in this series tackles a specific issue at the intersection of digital rights and the global pandemic in order to explore broader questions about how to protect fundamental rights in a time of crisis.

In our statement, we emphasised the principle that states must “defend freedom of expression and information”. In this fourth post of the series, we take a look at the issue of immunity passports, their technological appeal and their potentially sinister consequences on social inequality and fundamental rights The dangerous allure of science fiction Early in the coronavirus outbreak, pandemic guilty-pleasure film, Contagion, skyrocketed to the top of streaming sites’ most watched lists. One of the film’s most interesting plot points (mild spoiler alert) is the suggestion of a simple form of immunity passport.

Wristbands for people who have been vaccinated are presented as an obvious solution – and why wouldn’t they be? Various forms of immunity passport are a compelling idea. It sounds as if they could allow us to get back to a more normal life. But the reality is not as clear-cut as in the movies, and the threats to how we live our lives – in particular, the people that could be most harmed by such schemes – mean that we must be incredibly cautious. Consequently, as it stands now, the lack of evidence, combined with the size of the threat that these schemes pose to fundamental rights and freedoms, reveal that - digital or otherwise - immunity passports must not be rolled out.

Immunity passports – science fact says “no” In the last few weeks, “digital immunity passports”, certificates, apps, and other similar ideas have become prominent in discussions about how to exit from global lockdowns, with proposals popping up in Germany, Italy, Colombia, Argentina and the US to name a few. It is a legitimate policy goal to help people find safe ways to exist in this “new normal.”

Yet these proposals are all founded on the dangerous fallacy that we know and understand what coronavirus “immunity” looks like.

The WHO have been clear in their assessment that there is “currently no evidence” for immunity, and that such schemes may in fact incentivise risky behaviour. Medical journal The Lancet adds that such proposals are “impractical, but also pose considerable equitable and legal concerns even if such limitations are rectified.” And science journal Nature warns that immunity passports can actually harm public health. If public health experts are warning against immunity passports – even once we know more about COVID-19 immunity - then why are governments and private actors still pushing them as a silver bullet? Like with controversial tracking and contact tracing apps, there are a host of privacy and data protection concerns when such schemes become “digital”. Individual health data is very sensitive, as is data about our locations and interactions. As it is often with private companies that are aggressively pushing proposals (hello TransferWise and Bolt in Estonia), there are serious concerns about transparency, accountability, and who really benefits. EDRi has warned that public health tools should be open for public scrutiny, and limited in scope, purpose and time.

With private companies rushing to profit from this crisis, can we be confident that this will happen? The lessons learned from digital identification programmes suggests we have reasons to be very sceptical.

A new generation of “haves” and “have nots” The crux of the problem with immunity passports is that they will likely be used to decide who is and who is not allowed to participate in public life: who can go to work – and therefore earn money to support themselves and their family; who can go to school; and even who can stay in hotels. By essence, these “passports” could decide who can and who cannot exercise their fundamental rights.

As both Privacy International (PI) and Access Now explain, the law tells us that any restrictions on people’s rights must be really well justified, meeting high levels of necessity and proportionality, and must also have a clear legal basis. These criteria mean that measures that limit people’s rights must be demonstrably effective, have no viable alternative, not violate the essence of fundamental rights and have clear safeguards. This is a very high set of criteria that need to be met. In the context of an absence of scientific proof, significant risks created by false positives and false negatives and big concerns about data protection and privacy, the idea of digital immunity passports becomes even more sinister. This hasn’t stopped tech companies like Onfido lobbying their national health services or governments to adopt their services for biometric immunity passports.

Biometric surveillance and the risks of hyper-connected data In a wider sense, digital immunity passports – especially those linked to people’s sensitive biometric data – are part of a growing mass surveillance infrastructure which can watch, analyse and control people across time and place. Such systems rely on holding mass databases on people (which in itself comes with big risks of hacking and unauthorised sharing) and are damaging to the very core of people’s rights to dignity, privacy and bodily integrity. The combining of health data with biometric data further increases the ability of states and private actors to build up highly detailed, intrusive and intimate records of people. This can, in turn, have a chilling effect on freedom of expression and assembly by disincentivising people from joining protests, suppressing political opposition, and putting human rights defenders and journalists at risk. As Panoptykon Foundation have explained, such systems are ripe for abuse by governments looking to control people’s freedoms.

Discrimination and unequal impacts creating a segregated society It is foreseeable that the introduction of immunity passports will have unequal and disproportionate impacts upon those that already face the highest levels of poverty, exclusion and discrimination in society.

Those with the smallest safety nets, such as people in precarious and low-waged jobs, will be the ones who are least able to stay at home. The pressure to be allowed outside – and the impacts of not being allowed to do so - will therefore be unequally distributed. We know that some people are more at risk if they do contract the virus: those with underlying health conditions, older people and in the UK,black people.

This inequality of who suffers the most will replicate the already unequal distribution in our societies. And if immunity passports are administered digitally, then those without access to a device will be automatically excluded. This stratification of society by biological and health characteristics, as well as access to tech, is dangerous and authoritarian.

Don’t let science fiction become reality Digital immunity passports are no longer the preserve of science fiction. There is a very real risk that these schemes are putting innovation and appearance over public health, in a move often called “technosolutionism”. Digital and biometric immunity passports not only threaten the integrity of our sensitive bodily and health data, but create a stratified society where those who can afford to prove their immunity will have access to spaces and services that the remainder will not– de facto becoming second class citizens. The New York Times calls this “immunoprivilege.”

When the time comes that we have solid scientific evidence about immunity, it will be up to public health officials to work out how this can translate into certification, and for data protection and privacy authorities and experts to help guide governments to ensure that any measures strictly respect and promote fundamental rights and freedoms.

Until then, let’s rather focus on improving our national health systems, ensuring that research goes into preventing this and future pandemics (despite the push-back from Big Pharma) and that we build a new society free of virus such as COVID-19 and surveillance capitalism.

Read more:

>Local comment

Name: Remember me
E-mail: (optional)
Captcha

Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera

UK, EU reach landmark deal: All you need to know

The new deal will allow EU boats to continue fishing in UK waters before the first post-Brexit UK-EU summit.

Israel should be excluded from Eurovision, Spanish prime minister says

Spanish PM Pedro Sánchez says Israel should be excluded from the Eurovision Song Contest over its war in Gaza.

Gaza’s Khan Younis latest focus of Israeli forced displacement, bombing

Israeli army warns of 'unprecedented' assault on the southern city as dozens killed in strikes across blockaded enclave.

Moscow outlaws Amnesty International for ‘Russophobia’ amid Ukraine war

Russia claims members of the international rights group have backed 'extremist' organisations and 'foreign agents'.

Gary Lineker leaves BBC amid anti-Semitism row, pro-Palestinian comments

Britain's top football host is 'bowing out by mutual agreement' after backlash to a social media post about Zionism.

Chechnya’s Kadyrov wanted to resign. Or did he?

The Russian president is said to have denied Kadyrov's request.

Tanzanian opposition leader makes defiant appearance at treason trial

The trial has added to rising concerns across East Africa about threats to democracy.

What we know so far about Biden’s cancer diagnosis

US President Joe Biden has been diagnosed with an aggressive form of prostate cancer. Here’s what we know so far.

Car bomb in Pakistan’s restive southwest kills four people

The attack is just the latest in Balochistan, which is plagued by insurgency.

Romania, Poland, Portugal election results: Who are the winners and losers?

Pro-EU forces prevail on electoral 'super Sunday', but far right gains ground.

Cat caught smuggling drugs into prison in Costa Rica

A cat carrying packages of crack cocaine and marijuana was rescued by prison officers at the Pococi Penitentiary

Military and economic deals in pipeline as UK looks to EU reset

London and Brussels to remove selected post-Brexit barriers as Trump's global disruptions drive return to closer ties.

Israeli police break up protest against new Gaza assault

Anti-war protesters in Israel faced heavy police force after blocking a military road amid Gaza assault.

Gaza hospitals under siege and attack

The Indonesian Hospital in north Gaza is under siege after being bombarded in the latest Israeli attacks on hospitals.

Cheer up, people of Gaza! You’ll get killed on a full stomach

The new US humanitarian plan will ‘save us’, just like the previous ones did.

A father’s fight to find out what happened to his son who joined ISIS

When a 19-year-old Swede joined ISIL (ISIS), his father was left to bear the weight of his decision.

DR Congo’s coltan miners struggle as they dig to feed world’s tech

Despite global thirst for key tech material, miners in rebel-held Rubaya toil in poverty, mired in conflict and unrest.

Rains halt search for gold miners after deadly Indonesian landslide

Rescuers battle weather and conditions to find missing after storm kills six people at remote mine.

Video: Netanyahu says military will ‘take control’ of Gaza

Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu says the military is to 'take control of the entire territory of the Gaza Strip'.

Tens of thousands march in the Netherlands to protest against Gaza genocide

Protesters march through The Hague to call on government to do more to halt Israel’s onslaught on besieged enclave.

Mexican ship hits Brooklyn Bridge: What went wrong, who were the victims?

Two Mexican cadets are killed when the vessel, carrying 277 people, crashes into the New York landmark.

Biden’s prostate cancer: What happened, how serious is Gleason score 9?

Biden, 82, has been diagnosed with prostate cancer, the most common form of cancer in US males.

Iran summons UK charge d’affaires amid nuclear friction

Arrests of Iranians come amid lingering tensions over Iran's nuclear programme and fallout of Russia-Ukraine war.

Trump-Putin call: Could it lead to a Russia-Ukraine ceasefire?

The US president says only Putin and he can stitch together a truce. Their call on Monday will test that theory.

No aid yet after Israel proposes limited food for Gaza; offensive expands

Director-general of Gaza's Health Ministry says it's still unclear when border will open to allow humanitarian aid.

Powered by RSS 2 HTML

bignewsnetwork.com latest rss headlines

U.S. Senators Call for End to Gaza Blockade

WASHINGTON, DC - A coalition of 29 U.S. senators, spanning both parties, introduced a resolution on Thursday calling on the Trump administration to push for an immediate end to Israel's blockade of the Gaza Strip, citing dire humanitarian conditions and the need for renewed diplomacy in the region.

The resolution, led by Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and co-sponsored by prominent Democrats and Republic

Israeli military escalates hostilities in Gaza

GAZA - Israel Air Force pilots have heavily bombarded Gaza this week, killing hundreds and severely wounding hundreds more. 

The Israeli military on Friday topped off weeks of bombardment and heavy fighting, by announcing it was escalating its offensive. 

"Operation Gideon's Chariots" is the name of the new offensive, its intention, according to the IDF's Hebrew X page, is to seize

MIDEAST-GAZA-ISRAEL-IDF-GROUND INCURSION

(250519) -- JERUSALEM, May 19, 2025 (Xinhua) -- This photo released by Israel Defense Forces (IDF) on May 19, 2025 shows Israeli troops operating in the Gaza Strip. Israel on Sunday launched a major ground incursion into multiple areas of the Gaza Strip, marking a new phase in its conflict with Hamas. Meanwhile, it began easing the blockade to allow limited aid entry into the territory amid growing international pressu

Starve the people, miss the point: The cruel logic of sanctions

Often applied by the West as a tool to force countries into political changes, sanctions fail to achieve their objectives

Sanctions have become a preferred instrument in international diplomacy applied either to avoid war or when war is politically unpalatable. In theory, sections are meant to pressure countries into

Israel strikes over 160 "terror targets" in Gaza following Operation Gideon's Chariots

Tel Aviv [Israel], May 19 (ANI): Following the launch of Operation Gideon's Chariots, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) struck more than 160 terror targets across Gaza in a single day.

The strikes targeted northern, central, and southern Gaza, hitting underground infrastructure, weapons storage facilities, anti-tank missile posts, and terrorist cells.

Sharing a post on X, the IDF wrote, 'Update: Operation G

Israel Special Forces op kill senior terror commander in Khan Yunis, say unconfirmed Palestinian media reports

Tel Aviv [Israel], May 19 (ANI): According to unconfirmed Palestinian media reports, Israeli forces in Khan Yunis early Monday morning killed a senior Palestinian terror operative commander in the Popular Resistance Committees (PRC), the Press Service of Israel (TPS-IL) reported.

Media outlets in Gaza reported that Israeli special forces entered Khan Younis and killed Ahmad Sarhan, in an operation in the souther

Sixty years after he was executed in Syria, Mossad agent Eli Cohen's archives brought to Israel

Tel Aviv [Israel], May 19 (ANI): Documents and personal items belonging to famed Israeli spy Eli Cohen have been brought back to Israel from Syria to mark the 60th anniversary of his public execution in Damascus, the Israeli Prime Minister's Office has said.

The Prime Minister's Office on Sunday said that in a covert and complex Mossad operation, in cooperation with an allied foreign intelligence service, the off

Israel calls Operation Gideon's Chariot "new phase in fight against Hamas", lists objectives of mission

Tel Aviv [Israel], May 19 (ANI): The Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) has provided a comprehensive overview of its latest operations against Hamas. IDF Spokesperson Lt Col Nadav Shoshani listed down the major objectives of Operation Gideon's Chariot through a video message on Monday.

In the message, Lt Col Shoshani informed that the IDF ground forces advanced their operations in Northern and Southern Gaza.

'Aft

Israel escalates ground operations in Gaza, eases blockade amid humanitarian crisis

Since Israel resumed its military operations on March 18, 3,193 Palestinians have been killed and 8,993 others injured, bringing the overall death toll in Gaza since the conflict began in October 2023 to 53,339, with 121,034 others injured, according to health authorities in Gaza.

JERUSALEM, May 19 (Xinhua) -- Israel on Sunday launched a major ground incursion into multiple areas of the Gaza Stri

MIDEAST-GAZA-ISRAELI AIRSTRIKE-CASUALTY

(250519) -- GAZA, May 19, 2025 (Xinhua) -- Palestinians transfer bodies of victims killed in Israeli airstrikes at Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City on May 18, 2025. The death toll of Palestinians from Israeli attacks across the Gaza Strip since dawn on Sunday has risen to 140, according to the Civil Defense in Gaza. (Photo by Rizek Abdeljawad/Xinhua)

MIDEAST-GAZA-JABALIA REFUGEE CAMP-ISRAELI AIRSTRIKE-CASUALTY

(250519) -- GAZA, May 19, 2025 (Xinhua) -- People transfer an injured man after an Israeli airstrike in Jabalia refugee camp in northern Gaza Strip, on May 18, 2025.

The death toll of Palestinians from Israeli attacks across the Gaza Strip since dawn on Sunday has risen to 140, according to the Civil Defense in Gaza. (Photo by Abdul Rahman Salama/Xinhua)

Three Palestinians arrested for illegally working in Israel

Tel Aviv [Israel], May 19 (ANI/TPS): During an enforcement activity in the Central and Jerusalem region of the Enforcement and Foreigners Administration, three illegal residents from the areas of the Palestinian Authority were located working in businesses in the city of Rehovot. Specifically, they were found working in the kitchen of one of the city's restaurants.

An official investigation has been opened agains

Daily World Briefing, May 19

Trump to speak with Putin, Zelensky on Monday

U.S. President Donald Trump said on Saturday that he will speak separately with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on Monday to push for a ceasefire deal between the two countries.

"I will be speaking, by telephone, to President Vladimir Putin of Russia on Monday, at 10:00 a.m.," Trump said in a post on Truth Social, addi

Israel PM Netanyahu approves limited food aid to Gaza

Tel Aviv [Israel], May 19 (ANI): Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has stated that acting on the recommendations from the Israel Defence Forces (IDF), his cabinet has agreed to allow a 'basic quantity' of food after a nearly three-month blockade in Gaza that has brought Palestinians to the edge of famine, Euronews reported on Monday.

According to Euronews, this move is aimed at facilitating Israel's expan

Israel begins major ground offensive in Gaza

IDF troops have advanced into both the northern and southern areas of the enclave as part of Operation Gideons Chariots

Israel launched a large-scale ground campaign in Gaza on Sunday following a wave of overnight airstrikes that killed more than 100 people, according to local health officials.

The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) confirmed it had begun "extensive ground operations" across both

Powered by RSS 2 HTML


news resources
Afghanistan | Africa | Albania | Algeria | Andorra | Angola | Anguilla | Antigua | Argentina | Armenia | Aruba | Asia | Australia | Austria | Azerbaijan | Bahamas | Bahrain | Balkans | Bangladesh | Barbados | Belarus | Belgium | Belize | Benin | Bermuda | Bhutan | Bosnia | Bolivia | Botswana | Brazil | Brunei | Bulgaria | Burkina | Burma | Burundi | Cambodia | Cameroon | Canada | Cape Verde | Caribbean | Cayman Islands | Cen African Rep | Chad | Chile | China | Christmas Island | Columbia | Comoros | Congo | Cook Island | Costa Rica | Croatia | Cuba | Cyprus | Czech/Slovakia | Denmark | Djibouti | Dominican Republic | Dubai | East Timor | Ecuador | Egypt | El Salvador | Equatorial Guinea | Eritrea | Estonia | Ethiopia | Europe | Faroe Islands | Fiji | Finland | France | Gabon | Gambia | Georgia | Germany | Ghana | Greece | Greenland | Grenada | Guadeloupe | Guam | Guatemala | Guinea | Guyana | Haiti | Holland | Honduras | Hong Kong | Hungary | Iceland | India | Indonesia | Iran | Iraq | Ireland | Israel | Italy | Ivory Coast | Jamaica | Japan | Jordan | Kazakhstan | Kenya | Kiribati | Korea | Kuwait | Kyrgyzstan | Laos | Latvia | Lebanon | Lesotho | Liberia | Libya | Lietchtenstein | Lithuania | London | Luxembourg | Macau | Macedonia | Madagascar | Malawi | Malaysia | Maldives | Mali | Malta | Marshall Islands | Martinique | Mauritania | Mauritius | Mexico | Micronesia | Moldova | Monaco | Mongolia | Montenegro | Montserrat | Morocco | Mozambique | Namibia | Nauru | New Zealand | Nicaragua | Niue | Niger | Nigeria | Northern Ireland | Norway | Oman | Pakistan | Palau | Palestine | Panama | Paraguay | Peru | Philippines | Pitcairn Islands | Poland | Portugal | Qatar | Romania | Russia | Rwanda | Samoa | San Marino | Sao Tomé | Saudi Arabia | Scandinavia | Senegal | Serbia | Seychelles | Sierra Leone | Singapore | Slovakia | Slovenia | Solomon Islands | Somalia | South Africa | South Americas | Spain | Sri Lanka | St Kitts | St Lucia | St Pierre | St Vincent | Sudan | Suriname | Swaziliand | Sweden | Switzerland | Syria | Taiwan | Tajikistan | Tanzania | Thailand | Tibet | Togo | Tonga | Trinidad | Tunisia | Turkey | Turkmenistan | Turks & Caicos | Tuvalu | Uganda | Ukraine | United Kingdom | United States | Uruguay | Uzbekistan | Vanuatu | Venezuela | Vietnam | Virgin Islands | Walli & Futuna | Yemen | Zambia | Zimbabwe | World
Human Rights | Science | Journalism | Music | Showbiz | Sport | Technology
Clickable News Globe

Top | Privacy | Forum | Comment XML news feed directory MP3 Sounds | Links | Publicity | Contact
On-line Editing | Publish news | Guestbook | Site Status | Site Map
publish an item from this page to Newsvive.com Seed Newsvine
© Newsmedianews— Monday, 19 May 2025
on-line now for 10000 days.

Web newsmedianews

See traffic details for this site